My Favorite Secret
Playing Favorites, Book 3
Failed to add items
Sorry, we are unable to add the item because your shopping cart is already at capacity.
Add to basket failed.
Please try again later
Add to wishlist failed.
Please try again later
Remove from wishlist failed.
Please try again later
Adding to library failed
Please try again
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Audible Standard 30-day free trial
Select 1 audiobook a month from our entire collection.
Listen to your selected audiobooks as long as you're a member.
Get unlimited access to bingeable podcasts.
Standard auto renews for £5.99 a month after 30 days. Cancel anytime.
My Favorite Secret
Narrated by:
Lucy Rivers, Joe Arden, Lee Samuels
Buy Now for £15.24
-
Narrated by:
-
Lucy Rivers
-
Joe Arden
-
Lee Samuels
-
By:
-
Skyla Summers
About this listen
Felix and Tyler Blackwood are a sin I can’t stop craving. I have strict values about saving myself for marriage, but when I return from a vacation abroad, Felix and Tyler are no longer the innocent boys I grew up with and resisting them feels impossible. They’re now men, they’re gorgeous, and they’re tempting me to give in to forbidden desires.
I can hold out until we all start living together. They say I’ve always belonged to them and they’re more than willing to share me.
Before I know it, the three of us are entangled. What we’re doing is so wrong but feels too good to stop. We can keep it a secret. They’re mine and they promise me nothing will tear us apart. I want to believe them but I’m scared. Some secrets can kill. There’s one secret I know will be the death of us.
Written in multi POV, My Favorite Secret is the first book in Felix, Tyler, and Harper's duet. It is set before My Favorite Girl, contains an MFM relationship, and ends on a cliffhanger. The duet is a "second chance romance". The characters will find their happy ever after in the second book of the duet when they are in their late twenties.
For the best listening experience, it is recommended that you listen to My Favorite Girl and My Favorite Sin first to gain a deeper appreciation of the Blackwood family dynamics
©2025 Skyla Summers (P)2025 Blue Nose PublishingListener received this title free
Harper, Felix & Tyler are best friends who grew up together and made a blood pack when they were younger to always be each others. They are inseparable until Felix pulls away into a new crowd of friends and pulls away from their group. Harper is the good girl who always on the edge of wanting to but shouldn’t but being so tempted.
This Audiobook is an absolute dream these three voice actors sounded so perfect together. They really made you feel the chemistry between the characters.
Lucy has the perfect voice for young innocence and she absolute delivered on the emotion the break in her voice for some of the emotional scenes really hurt me. She was so perfect for Harper and the way she showcased Harpers possessive side and delivering her ‘Your Mine’ had me so obsessed! You really go on a journey in this books with Harper and Lucy delivers this so much with her portrayal of Harpers character.
I really enjoyed Lee Samuel’s as Tyler I think he was perfect he has a strong protecter voice that’s also so gentle and calming when speaking with Harper. I also loved the switch of when he decided he was having Harper and he had this possessiveness to his voice. I loved Tyler’s character and how much he loves Harper and they way he has always being there for her. Lee Samuel’s really showcased the hurt Tyler feels towards his father’s actions.
Joe Arden as Felix was everything I imagined he is exactly who I could picture voicing him. Felix is troubled from his relationship with his dad and Joe showcases that so well through the emotion he delivers as well as delivering the playful side of Felix. Felix makes a big change in character when Harper needs him and you could really feel the love Felix holds for Harper.
I can’t wait for the next book because that’s cliffhanger was brutal. I loved experiencing this taboo/forbbin love story and can’t wait to see what happens next.
I couldn’t stop listening to - this cast & story was perfection!
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Listener received this title free
Wow—this story wrecked me in the best possible way. This book was an emotional rollercoaster I was not prepared for.
This is one of those reads that has you clutching your chest in one chapter and fanning yourself in the next. The heat level? Absolutely feral. But what really makes it unforgettable is the depth of the characters and the tangled history between them.
Harper is the definition of the “good girl”—a disciplined ballerina shaped by expectations, sheltered, obedient, and aching for something more even if she doesn’t fully realize it yet. She grew up inseparable from brothers Tyler and Felix, until life, choices, and bad influences pulled Felix away, leaving fractures none of them knew how to name.
Felix completely stole my heart. He’s dangerous, layered, and morally grey—a walking contradiction. On the surface he’s reckless and abrasive, but underneath it all he’s intensely loyal and hopelessly fixated on Harper, even when she’s convinced he despises her. Tyler, on the other hand, wears the mask of responsibility: the dependable one, the academic, the best friend. But beneath that control is a man simmering with desire and dominance, terrified of crossing lines that can’t be uncrossed.
As the years pass and Harper comes into her own—especially after a life-changing trip abroad—everything shifts. She starts seeing Tyler not as her safe place, but as a man who wants her. Her volatile push-and-pull with Felix ignites into something neither of them can deny. Then tragedy strikes, forcing the three of them back into each other’s orbit, and all the buried longing, jealousy, and devotion explodes to the surface.
What follows is a beautifully forbidden, emotionally charged descent into temptation, where boundaries blur and nothing feels simple anymore. The connection between all three is intense, raw, and consuming. This isn’t just shock-value spice either—there’s real growth, real pain, and real transformation happening on the page.
The audiobook narration elevates this story to another level entirely. Lucy Rivers delivers Harper’s vulnerability and emotional turmoil with such authenticity that you feel every crack in her composure. Joe Arden and Lee Samuels embody Tyler and Felix perfectly, giving each brother a distinct presence and energy that mirrors their personalities—Tyler’s controlled intensity and Felix’s dangerous edge come through flawlessly. The emotional scenes hit harder, the tension feels tighter, and the spice? Even more intoxicating. Their performances pull you deeper into the story and make it impossible to disconnect from the characters.
The pacing is addictive, the emotions are brutal, and the ending? Absolutely soul-crushing. The cliffhanger hit exactly where it was meant to, and even though I knew it was coming, it still left me shattered and desperate for more. Skyla has an uncanny ability to rip your heart out while making you beg for the next chapter, and this book proves it yet again.
This is decadent, taboo, heartbreaking, and addictive. I’m all in, and I *need* the next book immediately.
I can’t wait for next one 😍😍
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Listener received this title free
My Favorite Secret Review
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Listener received this title free
This story follows two brothers who happen to love the same woman who loves them both back just as fiercely, my only issue was not being able to connect with Harpers character. If you are looking for an innocent fmc and a book full of spice check this out.
Wow its a spicy one
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.